Rough Ideas Read online

  Begin Reading

  Table of Contents

  A Note About the Author

  Copyright Page

  Thank you for buying this

  Farrar, Straus and Giroux ebook.

  To receive special offers, bonus content,

  and info on new releases and other great reads,

  sign up for our newsletters.

  Or visit us online at

  us.macmillan.com/newslettersignup

  For email updates on the author, click here.

  The author and publisher have provided this e-book to you for your personal use only. You may not make this e-book publicly available in any way. Copyright infringement is against the law. If you believe the copy of this e-book you are reading infringes on the author’s copyright, please notify the publisher at: us.macmillanusa.com/piracy.

  For Dennis

  without whom many of these reflections might be rougher … and more

  Introduction

  Give me a rough idea … not as in a deliberately coarse or unformed one, rather one that has a beginning but not yet an end.

  I spend a lot of my life sitting around – at airports, on planes, in hotel rooms – and most of this book expands notes I have made during that dead time on the road. Many of these jottings found their way into print, on paper or online, but others remained unfinished musings on scraps of paper or saved as files on the go on my iPhone: seeds, saplings, waiting to be planted or repotted or pruned.

  Mostly I’ve written about music and the life of a musician (not always the same thing), from exploring the broader aspects of what it is to walk out onto a stage or to make a recording to specialist tips from deep inside the practice room: how to trill, how to pedal, how to practise. Other subjects appear too, people I’ve known, places I’ve travelled to, books I’ve read, paintings I’ve seen. Even religion is there: the possibility of the existence of God, problems with some biblical texts and the challenge involved in being a gay Catholic, and abortion. I’ve placed these reflections in a separate section so that readers allergic to such matters can avoid them and we can remain friends.

  ‘How do you pronounce your name?’

  ‘Hough: rhymes with rough.’

  FORUM

  The Soul of Music

  Great buildings catch the eye but great concert halls must catch the ear too – and not just as spaces in which to hear music. Rather they are meant to be musical instruments, their walls and ceilings and floors catching, mixing, projecting the vibrations, transporting them through the air to the ear. A fine acoustic does not just make the music created onstage sound better; it is part of the creative process itself. When I strike a chord, what I hear instantly affects how I will play the next chord. Pianists do not press down predetermined keys with predetermined weight; we spin plates of sound in the air, reacting with split-second reflex to their curve and quiver. Adjustments of pedalling and nuance, of rhythmic flexibility or rigidity, are as constant as the dart and dance of a juggler. We play a hall more than play in a hall.

  Wigmore Street is a rather dull thoroughfare. Its buildings tend to be respectable and predictable. Above the shopfronts are offices with politely yawning windows, and the cheerful if not exactly cheap restaurants seem tolerated rather than celebrated. But then we reach number 36. Another shopfront it might seem, but no. Wigmore Street’s mediocre Victoriana has lightened. There is a twinkle in the eye as you notice a glass awning. This crystal umbrella is more than a protection against occasional rain. To build with glass is architectural liberation, and to stand safely covered yet still under open skies is a form of ecstasy.

  There are no bright lights outside number 36, nothing to distract one’s continuing amble towards John Lewis or Selfridge’s. Just, on both the east and west side of this glass awning, stencilled letters spelling WIGMORE HALL in one of the Arts and Crafts movement’s more sober fonts. Now you know that you are standing outside a building that has resonated with music for over a hundred years.

  Passing through the swinging wooden doors, inset with polished brass panels on which is also stencilled the name of the hall, you step into the outer lobby, a funnel through which all patrons pour. At the end of this corridor is the box office. A small window, as if from a country cottage lacking only a rambling rose, appears at waist level on the left. As you walk towards it only a hand is intermittently visible, dispensing envelopes containing tickets. It’s hard to see who owns the hand, even as one reaches the aperture, for to see the face of the owner of the hand requires a rather undignified bending down, in the hope that your name is on the list, that your ticket is safely reserved, that you’ve come on the correct evening. To the right of the window is a door where a man in evening dress is usually found leaning. This is someone who can override the authority of the armless hand, someone who can make sure that reservations are honoured and that honoured guests are admitted with no reservations. Often the door appears empty until the final approach when a slim figure sidles out, smiling, knowing. He holds an envelope in his hand. The exchange is made. You’re in.

  Immediately past this door to the left is a staircase going up, leading to the hall’s small balcony, which contains a mere 78 seats. I’ve sat up there a number of times and it has excellent acoustics and sight lines but it somehow has the feeling of last-minute admission, as if downstairs were oversold or you arrived late or there was a mix-up at the secret window. Or maybe it’s the opposite, and this is the place for that special guest of the performer, or that celebrity who wants to remain incognito, or that jaded music professional who wants an easy exit in the event of a tedious evening. If a concert has not sold well, a fat, red rope hangs at the bottom of the stairs, blocking entry.

  After the staircase there is a choice: left or right. Two doors leading into the holy of holies; no other way inside for the public in this small auditorium. Even if I’m sitting on the left side I nearly always enter by the right door, which is directly ahead of the street entrance. To enter by the left door, at the top of the basement staircase, suggests you have been loitering, or were in the loo, or were gulping down a gin and tonic in the bar. To go down to the bar during the interval is to be sociable; to go down there before the concert is to be … available.

  And so to your seat: red velvet; straight back and sides. A hand in the gap and a gentle push down. Not too comfortable, so you can focus and concentrate on the music; not too uncomfortable, so you can focus and concentrate on the music for a long time. Glance around to see if you know anyone. Oh lovely, there’s so-and-so. Oh dear, there’s so-and-so. Turn back and look down. Thank goodness you bought that substantial programme book.

  The stage is the centre of Wigmore Hall, its raison d’être and point of focus. It is also the dividing line between front of house and backstage. A concert is theatre – costumes, lighting, choreography – and its habits are not just thoughtless tradition. These customs can be the best preparation for the drama of the music to unfold – a reason, too, why we set aside special places for our concerts. As with churches, we use a separate building for this activity partly because we want to create a sacred space. A concert is a feast, a liturgy … a party even. It can be bad, but it should never be drab or routine.

  In 1899 the British architect Thomas Edward Collcutt, having finished Britain’s ‘first luxury hotel’, the Savoy, just over ten years earlier, was commissioned to design Wigmore Hall. It was his only concert hall. From the mid-twentieth century onwards acousticians emerged as a separate breed, commissioned by an architect to take his or her visual design and set it to music – scientists of sound. In earlier times the architect worked with the eye and hoped the ear would follow. It all appears to have been a matter of chance and tradition … and the shoebox.

  This rectangular s
hape was traditionally used for concert buildings, the stage a heel at one end. And size didn’t matter too much. As long as the proportions were right it would work. It has something to do with walls as arms embracing vibrations, enabling sound to be projected but contained. Wigmore’s shoebox is small (a slipper fit for Cinderella herself), with every sound beautifully focused. Materials are important: wood is warm, to the touch and to the ear. Wigmore’s stage is a curved cradle of wood, but out in the 545-seat auditorium are the heavier, grander materials of alabaster and marble. Indeed, despite its birth in the era of art nouveau, Wigmore Hall harks back to the Renaissance in style. There are candle sconces on the walls, and if altars were to project out between the flattened, pink-veined pillars, and oil paintings depicting the life of Christ or of the saints were to be hung above those altars, we might easily be in the private chapel of a minor Italian duke. But no, this is a solidly secular space. Indeed, the only iconography is the famous cupola above the stage, an exuberantly colourful mural entitled The Soul of Music.

  This is in the Arts and Crafts style and was designed by Gerald Moira, later to become principal of the Edinburgh College of Art, and executed by the sculptor Frank Lynn Jenkins, who was much in demand as a creator of decorative friezes. The Soul of Music figure is gazing up at the ‘Genius of Harmony’ – a ball of fire with rays reflected across the world under a deep-blue but clouded sky. On the left a musician plays as if in a trance, seeking inspiration from beyond. ‘Love’ is there too, carrying roses. She apparently represents the idea that a musician’s incentive must be love for art with beauty as the sole reward. On the right side is Psyche – the human soul – who inspires the seated composer to pen musical notes onto a scroll. The tangled nest of thorns that disturbs the perfection of this vision represents the possibility of humanity failing to live up to this artistic ideal – a choking by materialism. The whole image perhaps suggests music as religion. Such a message might well have shocked the post-Victorians who first received it, if they had not already been shocked by the erotic lurch of the Soul of Music figure, portrayed as a lithe, graceful, naked young man. This frieze is an unashamed display of exuberant naturalism in the pursuit of beauty and pleasure in music. On either side of the central cupola are two simpler rectangular paintings showing musicians responding successfully to the extravagant artistic suggestion of the central image.

  Returning to the stage, what about Wigmore Hall’s wings, the traditional theatrical term for the bits on the side where performers wait, often with extreme anxiety, for their moment to appear? Well, Wigmore’s wings are more like two ears. On the back wall of the stage are two symmetrical doors for entry and exit. The door on the right, as you face the stage, through which every artist walks, is mysterious. Wherever you sit in the hall it is impossible to see clearly behind the door because of a twist in the space, and then a thick crimson curtain blocks further view. But on the left there is a yet more mysterious door. It looks exactly the same, but no. This is a sort of broom cupboard leading via some precipitous steps directly up to the Green Room. It’s not used for public events. It’s too informal somehow, too cramped, too prosaic for the stage. This left door is gauche. It’s for Hilda Ogden rather than Maria Callas.

  Leaving the stage and walking through the right door we reach (left, up and left again) the Green Room. I’m old enough to remember auditioning at Wigmore Hall when this was pretty much all there was backstage: a room with an upright piano and a few pieces of shabby furniture. It was merely a place to hang your hat and don your tails before playing your concert. It is a room in which I have experienced many conflicting emotions, from the tremble of nervous anticipation as I warm up on the well-worn piano to the exhilaration and relief at the end of a concert, a glass of chilled champagne in hand. ‘Darling, what a performance!’ ‘I’ve never heard that piece played like that!’ ‘How do you think it went?’ ‘Dear, I’m speechless!’ … some of the classic phrases expressing dissatisfaction or bitchy venom while still appearing to offer a crumb of praise to the hungry, self-doubting artist.

  In 1992 a major restructuring added the Gerald Moore and Geoffrey Parsons rooms, rehearsal spaces named after two great accompanists – a reminder that Wigmore Hall has always had song at its heart, and that lieder require the piano to unfold the drama of a song as an equal partner. It also emphasises that Wigmore Hall is vitally, spiritually in the centre of Europe. So many of the thousands driven from their houses by jackboots found a home at Wigmore. It became a secular synagogue for those for whom the German language was a mother tongue, even if the Fatherland had made them orphans. Schubert, Schumann, Brahms, Wolf … comforting common currency for these refugees.

  The hall was built by the piano manufacturer C. Bechstein, which had its London showroom next door. This performing space was originally named Bechstein Hall. During the First World War the passing of the Trading with the Enemy Amendment Act in 1916 meant that all the assets of the Bechstein company were seized, including the hall. It eventually re-opened in 1917 as Wigmore Hall and now, a century later, it flourishes as never before.

  Buildings are homes to memories. ‘If only these walls could talk,’ we say. At 36 Wigmore Street, we might wish that they could sing.

  ‘Our concert halls are like museums’ – Yes, isn’t that great!

  I have a number of books by my bedside, ones I can dip into if only for a few minutes before I fall asleep. One of them is Rendez-vous with Art by Philippe de Montebello, Director of New York’s Metropolitan Museum of Art for thirty-one years until 2008, and the art critic Martin Gayford. As I leafed through it the other night, seeing photos of some favourite paintings, I was struck by how some familiar artworks seem like dear friends. As the years pass it’s as if we’ve grown old together. To contemplate these images again and again is constantly enriching and – so far – I’ve never felt jaded or bored by the repetition.

  We look at a painting and it looks back at us. We stare at its detail with eyes of wonder as it strips away the varnish coating our own thoughts and memories. Great art in all its forms demands to be revisited. It requires time. To read a poem once is not to have read it properly. I opened at random at Titian’s Christ Carrying the Cross, its combination of specificity and universality – Jesus of Nazareth, yes, but also every person who has ever helped or been helped in a moment of suffering – seemed to me to have depths of richness to last more than a lifetime.

  In the musical world I often hear the complaint that concert life is dying because we have made our auditoriums into museums, repeating the same old chestnuts year after year. This can be true, but is it really a problem? I’m not suggesting for a moment that it’s not important to have the opportunity to hear contemporary music or that we shouldn’t be curious and passionate about neglected works and composers, but let’s not disparage the classics in our permanent collections.

  When I visit a museum, I want to be surprised and stimulated and even shocked. But I also want to see the familiar masterpieces – not because I feel comfortable with what I already know but because the greatest art will continue to surprise, stimulate and shock, time after time.

  No one at London’s National Gallery would suggest that Van Eyck’s Arnolfini Wedding has outlived its interest and should spend some time in the storeroom but I have heard people say that they’d be happy never to hear a certain Beethoven work again. If a performer ever feels bored playing such well-known music then he or she is probably equally unsuited to playing newer works too. If Beethoven seems dull or old hat to us, then we need to listen to his music not less but more … more carefully, more intensely.

  We might need to hang or light a painting better, display it alongside something different, rethink our education programme, communicate the painting’s beauty and significance more imaginatively, even send it to a restorer, but let’s not just remove it from the wall or apologise for it. A curator – of art or music – needs to have complete confidence in the collection. There will always be someone who is see
ing a certain painting for the first time, hearing a certain piece of music for the first time, and for someone else it will be a chance to revisit a dear old friend.

  Music in churches: magical ghosts or profane distractions?

  Although churches were not designed for classical concerts, there is something magical about borrowing them for the evening. There are (friendly) ghosts in these buildings, smells of linen and wax, creaks from pew and sanctuary, strange shadows in cool, dusty corners, and so often, above all, acoustics that glow and pulsate, adding richness to the already rich sounds of the music. Strangely, it can be easier to lose the heavy weight of the ego where your performance is encouraged and appreciated but is not essential to the life of a building: a kind of bringing down to earth as the music itself soars to heaven.

  In the past there were few secular concerts in places of worship. Strictly speaking, concerts are still banned in Roman Catholic churches – as I found out when I offered in vain to give a benefit concert in one in New York a number of years ago. However, I did play once in Bari, with the permission of the bishop, over the tomb of St Nicholas … Santa Claus himself. It was the Liszt B minor Sonata at a crushingly slow tempo owing to the extreme and resonant echo of the ancient stone. It’s a strange experience to hear bar 35 still ringing in the air when your fingers are already playing bar 42.

  These days many churches are not only venues for concerts but make superb recording spaces as well. Some are deconsecrated and others still thrive as places of worship. I’ve made dozens of recordings in them – St George’s, Brandon Hill; Henry Wood Hall; Rosslyn Hill Chapel; All Saints’, Finchley; All Saints’, Tooting.